Saturday, July 25, 2026
BRIANNA
Nicole Austin
Questioning Culture · Following Facts · Telling Stories That Matter
Politics

Texas Drops Its NCAA Women’s Sports Lawsuit, Nearly Two Years On

November 19, 2026

Texas Drops Its NCAA Women’s Sports Lawsuit, Nearly Two Years On

On Thursday, November 12, lawyers for the Texas attorney general’s office told a state district court in Lubbock that the state would not go forward with its lawsuit against the NCAA — the case accusing the association of deceptively marketing women’s college sports because transgender athletes were permitted to compete in them. The Texas Tribune, which reported the filing on November 13, said the attorney general’s office did not respond to requests for comment, and that Bloomberg Law first reported it. Nothing in the reporting says whether the dismissal was with or without prejudice, so for now it is simply over, without any ruling on whether the claim was sound.

The suit was filed in December 2024 under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, a consumer-protection statute designed to address false advertising. In the announcement from then-Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office, the state asked for a permanent injunction barring the NCAA from allowing what it called biological males to compete in women’s events in Texas or involving Texas teams — or, failing that, an order requiring the association to stop marketing mixed-sex events as women’s competitions. “When people watch a women’s volleyball game, for example, they expect to see women playing against other women,” Paxton said. “Radical ‘gender theory’ has no place in college sports.”

What strikes me, reading the petition two years on, is how much of the ground it stood on has already shifted. Fights over who belongs in a category have a way of outliving the particular rule that started them, as anyone who has followed the longer arc of transgender history can attest — but they do not usually outlive it this visibly. As I noted previously, the outrage from the right about “men is women’s sports” is a solution in search of a problem.

Six weeks after the suit was filed, the NCAA answered the question itself. On February 6, 2025, the NCAA Board of Governors announced a new participation policy, citing President Trump’s executive order. In the women’s category, only student-athletes assigned female at birth may compete. Those assigned male at birth may still practice with women’s teams and receive benefits such as medical care, but not compete. The men’s category remains open regardless of sex assigned at birth. President Charlie Baker said the association believed “clear, consistent, and uniform eligibility standards would best serve today’s student-athletes.” The change took effect immediately.

The timing of the dismissal is difficult to separate from the November 3 election. Paxton lost his bid for the U.S. Senate, and Democrat Nathan Johnson defeated Republican Mayes Middleton for attorney general. Johnson has said he intends to review lawsuits brought under his predecessor and stop spending the office’s resources on those he considers political. The Tribune reports that the office has dropped at least two other cases since the election: one seeking to shut down FIEL, a Houston immigrant-rights organization, and one against Annunciation House, an El Paso migrant shelter.

How you read this depends on what you thought the suit was for. Those who backed it can fairly say the point was carried: ticket buyers, in their view, were owed an accurate description of what they were paying to watch, and the NCAA tightened its rules within weeks. Those who opposed it will say a false-advertising statute was stretched to settle a contested social question that belonged to sports governing bodies, legislatures, or Congress — and that a case abandoned without a ruling leaves the legal theory untested. Both readings can be true at once. The Texas NCAA lawsuit never produced a decision about whether consumer-protection law reaches this territory, which means the next attorney general who wants to try is not bound by anything that happened here.

That pattern is familiar by now. Much of what has been decided about transgender athletes this past year arrived through agency action, withdrawn rules, and procedural exits rather than verdicts — a Title IX case against the NCAA dismissed in October, a Virginia sports rule quietly withdrawn, a Supreme Court ruling that let state bans stand.

So a case closes in Lubbock, and almost no one announces it. For the handful of college athletes whose eligibility all of this was nominally about, the practical answer was settled in a boardroom in February 2025, long before any judge got near it. That is worth sitting with: the loudest arguments are not always the ones that decide anything.

The weekly, in your inbox.

One thoughtful piece a week, plus what's behind it.

Weekly Commentary · Behind the Story · New Articles · Book Updates

Reach this readership

Independent reporting and commentary on transgender life, read worldwide. Sponsorship keeps it going.

Sponsor Brianna