Saturday, July 25, 2026
BRIANNA
Nicole Austin
Questioning Culture · Following Facts · Telling Stories That Matter
Politics

Lawsuit Seeks to Block Washington’s I-638 Transgender Sports Ban Before Dec. 3

November 16, 2026

Lawsuit Seeks to Block Washington’s I-638 Transgender Sports Ban Before Dec. 3

A coalition of Washington families, the state teachers’ union and the nonprofit TransFamilies sued on November 9 to block Initiative 638, the voter-approved measure barring transgender girls from girls’ school sports and requiring sex verification. It takes effect December 3; no hearing date has been reported.

The suit is the first court test of a measure Washington voters approved on November 3, and it adds a new chapter to the long legal record traced in our transgender history and education hub. What follows is what the parties have filed, what each side argues, and what remains unsettled, drawn from the complaint itself and from reporting by KUOW, The Seattle Times, The Spokesman-Review, the Lynnwood Times, RealClearPolitics and Fox News.

What does the lawsuit against I-638 ask the court to do?

It asks King County Superior Court to declare the initiative unconstitutional and to block it from being enforced, first through a preliminary injunction and then permanently.

According to the complaint posted by Legal Voice, dated November 9, 2026, the only defendant is the State of Washington. The plaintiffs are seven parents filing under pseudonyms on behalf of their minor children, along with TransFamilies, a Seattle nonprofit that supports families with transgender children, and the Washington Education Association, the state’s largest teachers’ union. KUOW reported that the families have daughters who play school sports and that two of those athletes are transgender girls.

The ACLU of Washington and Legal Voice represent the families and TransFamilies; Pacifica Law Group represents the teachers’ union. The complaint requests a declaratory judgment, a preliminary and a permanent injunction, and attorneys’ fees. Per KUOW’s November 10 report on the filing, the plaintiffs want the court to act before the measure’s December 3 effective date, arguing that the timing would push families into hurried, mid-season medical appointments.

What does Initiative 638 require?

It bars students the measure defines as biologically male from girls’ school sports and requires any student who wants to compete on a girls’ team to submit a health care provider’s verification of her sex.

The complaint describes Section 3 of the initiative as requiring school boards and nonprofit bodies such as the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) to keep biologically male students out of girls’ competition. Under the measure, providers may rely only on reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels. The Lynnwood Times reported that the rule applies at public schools and certain private schools. The measure was sponsored by Let’s Go Washington, a political committee backed by Redmond hedge fund manager Brian Heywood, and passed with about 56% of the vote. We covered the result and the verification language in our earlier report on the I-638 vote.

How verification would work in practice is one of the central disputes. KUOW described the options as a genital exam, a hormone test, or a chromosome test. Supporters describe something far simpler: Let’s Go Washington told Fox News that existing sports physicals could satisfy the requirement. A family physician speaking through the campaign told The Spokesman-Review that the initiative “does not require exams of any kind.” Readers unfamiliar with some of the terms used on both sides can find plain-language definitions in our terminology guide.

What legal claims do the plaintiffs make?

They argue the initiative violates four provisions of the Washington Constitution, along with the state’s anti-discrimination protections.

The complaint cites the privacy guarantee in Article I, Section 7; the state’s Equal Rights Amendment, Article XXXI, because the verification requirement applies to girls’ sports but not boys’ sports; Article IX, Section 1, which guarantees education without discrimination on account of sex; and Article II, Section 37, the rule that a law amending another must set out the amended statute in full. On that last point, the plaintiffs argue that I-638 changes the Washington Law Against Discrimination, which already covers gender identity, and several education and parental-rights statutes without doing so openly.

“Washington educators are committed to fair and welcoming schools where all students can thrive,” teachers’ union president Janie White said, as reported in The Seattle Times’ account of the lawsuit, republished by Education Week. Adrien Leavitt, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Washington, said the initiative “seeks to deny transgender girls those opportunities.” KUOW reported that the union said its members would be “required to implement and explain the verification regime,” and that the parent of a 12th-grade transgender athlete said the requirements would cause her daughter “severe harm and compromise her well-being.”

How have the initiative’s supporters responded?

Supporters say the measure protects fairness in girls’ sports, reflects a clear voter decision, and has been mischaracterized by the lawsuit.

Darren Littell, executive director of Let’s Go Washington, said opponents’ “true colors are showing” and that the group looks forward to the attorney general defending the law. He told KUOW the plaintiffs’ claims about sex verification rest on “false assumptions.” He described the approach used in other states as a simple question: “Is this individual eligible for girls’ sports, yes or no?” Spokeswoman Hallie Herzberg told RealClearPolitics that “voters made their opinion on boys in girls’ sports loud and clear.”

Supporters have also pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court. On June 30, 2026, the Court ruled 6-3 that West Virginia and Idaho may bar transgender girls from girls’ school teams, a decision summarized in our post on the Supreme Court upholding state sports bans. That ruling addressed federal law; the Washington suit rests instead on the state constitution. State law has already proved decisive elsewhere: on November 4, a New York appeals court declared Nassau County’s ban on transgender athletes illegal under state anti-discrimination law, as covered in our report on the Nassau County ruling. For analysis of how the 2026 ruling has played out, see The Transgender Sports Ruling, One Season Later and the commentary A Solution in Search of a Problem.

Who will defend I-638 in court?

An outside law firm, Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, appointed by Attorney General Nick Brown, will defend the measure for the state.

Brown announced the appointment on November 12. “My personal views do not dictate what laws get defended or the strength of that defense,” he said, according to the Lynnwood Times’ report on the appointment. He described outside counsel as a routine step when his office cannot handle a case itself because of a conflict of interest, a need for specialized expertise, or workload. He said his office’s work on transgender rights would continue: “We will not and cannot abandon that work.” A day earlier, his office had told Fox News that its role is to defend new laws “regardless of our personal views about the policy.”

The appointment drew criticism from conservatives. KUOW reported that critics saw conflicts in the office’s past arguments against similar bans and in the fact that Brown’s former firm, Pacifica Law Group, represents the teachers’ union. State Rep. Matt Marshall, a Republican, questioned the choice of Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, citing the firm’s 2023 pro bono work challenging a Missouri rule that restricted gender-affirming care, the Lynnwood Times reported.

A second defender may also join. On November 13, Alliance Defending Freedom filed a motion asking the court to let Female Athletes United intervene as a defendant, supported by declarations from five female athletes, Fox News reported. “We’re asking to be allowed to step in and help the state of Washington defend the validity of the law,” ADF attorney Hal Frampton said. The motion is a request; no ruling has been reported.

What happens before December 3?

Unless a judge blocks it, I-638 takes effect on December 3; as of the most recent reporting reviewed for this article, no hearing on the injunction request had been scheduled.

The WIAA told KUOW it will follow state law and is prepared to make “necessary changes” by December 3. Separately, RealClearPolitics reported that the Seattle Public Schools board held an emergency meeting on November 9 and authorized the district’s superintendent and legal counsel to take legal action over the measure; no district filing had been reported as of this writing.

Washington’s sports policy is also before the U.S. Supreme Court in a separate federal case brought by a high school wrestler and her mother, described in our report on the Washington wrestling case. That emergency application had not been decided as of RealClearPolitics’ November 11 report. Voters in Colorado and Arizona also approved measures on transgender athletes on November 3, following ballot campaigns outlined in our preview of the Colorado and Washington ballot measures. For background on recurring questions in these disputes, see our transgender FAQs.

Frequently asked questions about the I-638 lawsuit

What is Washington Initiative 638?

Initiative 638 is a voter-approved Washington measure that bars students it defines as biologically male from girls’ school sports and requires girls who want to compete to submit a health care provider’s verification of sex. Voters approved it by about 56% on November 3, 2026.

Who filed the lawsuit against I-638?

Seven parents of student-athletes filing under pseudonyms, the nonprofit TransFamilies and the Washington Education Association filed suit on November 9, 2026, in King County Superior Court. The ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice, and Pacifica Law Group represent them.

What does the I-638 lawsuit argue?

The complaint argues the initiative violates the Washington Constitution’s privacy guarantee, its Equal Rights Amendment, its guarantee of education without sex discrimination, and its rule on amending existing laws. It also argues the verification requirement applies only to girls.

When does I-638 take effect?

The initiative is scheduled to take effect on December 3, 2026. The plaintiffs have asked the court for a preliminary injunction that would stop it from taking effect while the case proceeds.

Why is an outside law firm defending I-638?

Attorney General Nick Brown appointed Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner on November 12, 2026. He said outside counsel is a routine step when his office faces a potential conflict of interest, needs specialized expertise, or has workload limits, and that his personal views do not dictate how laws are defended.

Is I-638 blocked right now?

No. As of the reporting reviewed for this article, no judge had ruled on the request for a preliminary injunction and no hearing date had been reported. The measure remains scheduled to take effect on December 3, 2026.

The weekly, in your inbox.

One thoughtful piece a week, plus what's behind it.

Weekly Commentary · Behind the Story · New Articles · Book Updates

Reach this readership

Independent reporting and commentary on transgender life, read worldwide. Sponsorship keeps it going.

Sponsor Brianna