November 19, 2026

A Missoula County judge on Nov. 17 blocked enforcement of the Montana sex definition law, Senate Bill 437, which defines sex as binary based on a person’s reproductive system. The preliminary injunction holds while the lawsuit continues; it is not a final ruling.
The order is the latest turn in a multiyear fight over how Montana law defines sex, a dispute that fits a longer pattern of legal efforts to fix sex classifications in statute, traced in our transgender history and education hub. What follows is what the court ordered, what the law does, how it relates to an earlier law the courts struck down, and what each side has said, drawn from reporting by Montana Free Press and NonStop Local and from a statement by the governor’s office.
District Judge Leslie Halligan of Missoula County granted the plaintiffs a preliminary injunction, which means the state cannot enforce SB 437 while the case proceeds.
According to Montana Free Press’s report on the ruling, Halligan wrote that the injunction is meant to “avert inconsistent enforcement of a statute that plaintiffs have shown is likely unconstitutional.” She found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on claims that the law violates the rights to privacy and equal protection under the Montana Constitution, and that enforcing it would cause ongoing irreparable harm.
A preliminary injunction is a temporary order. It reflects the judge’s view of how the case is likely to come out, not a final decision on whether the law is constitutional. The coverage reviewed for this article did not describe whether the order applies to everyone in Montana or only to the plaintiffs, or which specific provisions of the law it reaches.
SB 437 writes new definitions of “male,” “female,” “sex” and “gender” into wide-ranging sections of Montana law, tying sex to a person’s reproductive system.
As Montana Free Press explained when the bill became law in March, the law defines female and male by primary sexual anatomy: a female is a person whose reproductive system uses ova for fertilization, and a male is a person whose system uses sperm, including a person who would have that system but for a congenital anomaly or a disruption. The law also adds definitions of man, woman, father and mother, and states that “gender” is a synonym for “sex” and may not be read as meaning gender identity, gender expression or gender role.
The definitions reach more than 60 sections of state law, according to the same report, including those governing driver’s licenses, marriage licenses, anti-discrimination protections in employment, and gender-balance requirements for state boards, commissions and political party precinct committees. Readers unfamiliar with the vocabulary at issue can find the distinctions between sex, gender identity and gender expression in our transgender terminology guide.
SB 437 is largely similar to Senate Bill 458, a 2023 law that a Montana court declared unconstitutional twice, and the judge found the two laws appear to have the same practical effect.
Montana Free Press reported that SB 458 was struck down first in June 2024, because its subject was not clearly expressed in its title, and again in February 2025, when a judge found it violated the equal protection clause of the Montana Constitution.
In court, the state pointed to differences between the two laws and argued that SB 437 does not demand access to private information. Halligan wrote that the question is not whether SB 437 uses “precisely the same words” as SB 458, but whether the differences change the constitutional analysis. She concluded that the law’s “operative effect” appears to be the same, according to Montana Free Press.
Republican legislative leaders held the bill after it passed in April 2025, saying they wanted to keep it from being drawn into the litigation over SB 458; it was signed on March 24, 2026.
The bill, sponsored by Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, passed both chambers in mid-April 2025, largely along party lines. Montana Free Press reported that it was signed by the Senate president within days but then sat with House Speaker Brandon Ler. In August 2025, a spokesperson for House Republicans told the outlet that leadership had chosen to hold the bill “to prevent it from being immediately tied up with ongoing litigation.” The Legislature’s legal services director said the joint rule on sending bills to the governor is discretionary. Ler and Gov. Greg Gianforte both signed the bill on March 24, 2026.
The plaintiffs’ lawyers have criticized that delay. Molly Danahy, litigation director at Upper Seven Law, the Helena-based nonprofit representing the plaintiffs, called the year-long hold one of several “procedural shenanigans” and said they could not save the law from ordinary constitutional review.
The governor and House speaker say SB 437 sets out a biologically based definition of sex that does not restrict how transgender people identify, and that the state will defend it in court.
In a March 31 statement from Gov. Gianforte and Speaker Ler, issued after the challengers moved to halt the law, the two said the law “codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex, male and female,” while protecting people born intersex and “not infringing on transgender individuals’ ability to identify with whatever gender, but not sex, they wish.” They said the Legislature “acted deliberately” with the possibility of litigation in mind and that the state “will defend this duly enacted law.”
After the ruling, a spokesperson for the governor’s office told Montana Free Press that the office generally does not comment on ongoing litigation and pointed to that earlier statement. The coverage reviewed for this article did not include a statement from the attorney general’s office or say whether the state plans to appeal the injunction.
The plaintiffs, a group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans, argue that the law is unconstitutional and forces them to disclose private medical information.
Danahy said in a press release quoted by Montana Free Press that after the court found the state’s first attempt unconstitutional, “the Legislature made a second attempt to pass essentially the same law.” NonStop Local’s report on the injunction quoted Halligan’s finding that the harms at issue “affect Plaintiffs’ privacy, equal treatment, and legal recognition.”
Montana Free Press’s earlier coverage of the 2023 law described how such definitions play out in daily life: a plaintiff in that case worried about holding a driver’s license whose sex marker did not match their appearance when applying for housing or showing identification. Disputes over sex markers on identity documents have surfaced elsewhere as well, including in Ohio’s driver’s license gender marker policy and the federal fight over passport gender markers.
The lawsuit continues in Missoula County District Court, and SB 437 remains unenforceable while the injunction stands.
Montana Free Press reported that the plaintiffs filed their complaint on April 6, the state responded on May 22, and the court heard arguments on the injunction on June 19. The ruling came five months later. No trial date had been reported in the coverage reviewed for this article, and no appeal of the injunction had been reported. Either side’s next filing could change that, so the status described here reflects reporting through Nov. 19, 2026. For background on common questions about these legal disputes, see our transgender FAQs.
Senate Bill 437 is a 2025 Montana law that defines “male,” “female,” “sex” and “gender” across more than 60 sections of state law, tying sex to a person’s reproductive system and treating gender as a synonym for sex.
No. On Nov. 17, 2026, Missoula County District Judge Leslie Halligan granted a preliminary injunction that stops the state from enforcing the law while the lawsuit proceeds. It is a temporary order, not a final ruling on the law’s constitutionality.
Judge Halligan found that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that SB 437 violates the rights to privacy and equal protection under the Montana Constitution, and that enforcing it would cause ongoing irreparable harm.
SB 458 was a similar 2023 law that a Montana court struck down in June 2024 and again in February 2025. The state argued SB 437 differs and does not require private information; the judge found its operative effect appears to be the same.
A group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans filed the suit. They are represented by Upper Seven Law, a Helena-based nonprofit law firm.
The law cannot be enforced while the injunction remains in place. As of reporting through Nov. 19, 2026, no trial date and no appeal of the injunction had been reported.
More in Politics
Explore by theme
See all in PoliticsOne thoughtful piece a week, plus what's behind it.
Reach this readership
Independent reporting and commentary on transgender life, read worldwide. Sponsorship keeps it going.
Sponsor Brianna