November 20, 2026

On Tuesday, November 17, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit declined to put its own work on hold. In a one-page per curiam order in Nicolas Talbott, et al. v. United States of America, et al., No. 25-5087, the court denied the government’s motion to stay issuance of the mandate while it asks the Supreme Court to take the case, and directed the clerk to issue that mandate “forthwith.” The clerk did so the same day. With that, the transgender troops ruling the panel handed down on June 1 stopped being a document and started being an obligation.
It is worth being precise about how much that covers, because the headline is larger than the order. The injunction now in force does not protect transgender service members generally, and it does nothing for people trying to enlist. As Judge Robert Wilkins put it in a statement attached to the order, “this injunction has been narrowed to cover only a limited group of currently serving Plaintiffs.” Lawyers for those plaintiffs put the number at 27. For everyone else in uniform, the policy still applies.
The road here has been long and jagged. President Trump’s January 2025 executive order directed the Pentagon to bar transgender people from service; Judge Ana Reyes of the federal district court in Washington blocked it that March. In May 2025, in a separate case out of Washington state, the Supreme Court let the policy take effect while litigation continued — a pattern anyone following transgender history in this country will recognize, where the law moves and then moves back. The D.C. Circuit ruled against the policy on the merits in June. The government petitioned the Supreme Court in August; that petition, No. 26-272, was distributed on November 17 for the justices’ December 4 conference.
Wilkins’s statement is the closest thing the order has to reasoning, and it turns on a narrow point: the government did not carry its burden. “In its motion, the government has not alleged any irreparable harm,” he wrote, noting that such injury must be “certain and great” and “actual and not theoretical.” He added that the Department “has never specified” what national security “risks” would follow from keeping these particular plaintiffs — decorated people who, the government has not contested, served honorably. And he distinguished the 2025 Supreme Court stay on the ground that it concerned a universal injunction reaching both retention and enlistment, while this one has been cut down to a handful of names. On the merits, he wrote that the policy classifies “based on gender identity, not gender dysphoria,” and that the only justification offered was the “foundational premises” of the policy itself — “such ‘stereotyping’ is not a legitimate government interest.”
Judge Justin Walker saw it differently. The order records simply that he “would grant this motion,” and he did not explain why there. In his June dissent he had argued that the Constitution assigns questions of military composition to Congress and the president, and that judges have “neither the expertise nor the authority” to decide whether the military may exclude these plaintiffs. That is not a small objection, and it is the government’s central one: the Pentagon maintains the policy rests on gender dysphoria rather than transgender status, and that courts owe deference to military judgments about readiness and deployability. Twenty-two states and a group of retired officers filed briefs supporting that view. Judge Judith Rogers, a senior judge, rounded out the panel; the denial was 2-1.
So what actually changed on Tuesday? For 27 people — several of whom had been placed on administrative leave with separation boards scheduled — a good deal. For the policy, almost nothing yet. Military.com reported that a trial before Judge Reyes is set for January. The justices meet on December 4. Previous rounds of this fight have already reshaped separation pay and service extensions for people who did not win a court order.
I keep returning to a detail in Wilkins’s statement: that the government, asked to say what harm would come from letting these soldiers keep working, did not answer. Twenty-seven careers are continuing this week because no one could articulate a reason they shouldn’t. That is a win. It is also a thin and provisional thing to stand on, and everyone involved knows it.
More in Politics
Explore by theme
See all in PoliticsOne thoughtful piece a week, plus what's behind it.
Reach this readership
Independent reporting and commentary on transgender life, read worldwide. Sponsorship keeps it going.
Sponsor Brianna